In fact, this is the exact situation that happens with Vision in Infinity War, and it would have likely been too repetitive to have it happen with Steve Rogers as well. Forever a rock n roll aficionado, he's also an unapologetic KISS and Trans-Siberian Orchestra fan. the Red Skull. Though they have major impacts on the Marvel universe as we know it, the six Infinity Stones are fairly easy to understand in terms of their powers and capabilities. Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, In Avengers: Endgame, it wasn't utilized except for the two snaps from Smart Hulk and Tony Stark. Captain America Encountered Red Skull to Return Soul Stone Home Movies Movie News Captain America Encountered Red Skull to Return Soul Stone, Confirm Directors By Andrew Marshall Published May 13, 2019 Avengers: Endgame directors Anthony & Joe Russo have confirmed Steve Rogers encountered the Red Skull when returning the Soul Stone to Vormir. New York, Both Romanoff and Barton were determined to sacrifice themselves so the other could get the stone and had a fight over who should stay alive and return with it; however, after a tense struggle, Romanoff won and decided to sacrifice herself falling into the abyss, allowing Barton to obtain the Stone soon afterward. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. But how would that have worked, exactly? Avengers Endgame directors SPEAK OUT on THAT potential Captain America reunion off . It turns out the Space Stone had transported him there in 1945, where he became the Keeper of the Soul Stone. He's been in love with comics for a very long time, and believes there is some good to be found even in the industry's more difficult times. @piggles44 chimed in. SPOILER WARNING: The following article contains major spoilers for Avengers: Endgame. Oct 3, 2022 4:38 PM EDT. Red Skull explained that the only way to acquire the Soul Stone was to give up one's soul but it had to be the soul of someone he loved. Knowing this, an interesting question is raised about Captain Americas final mission: how does one go about returning the Soul Stone? At the end of the 2018-2019 Infinity Wars event, Adam Warlock gave sentience to the Infinity Stones and sent them flying across the cosmos to find living hosts. This is a matter that vigorously rolled around in my head following my first screening of Avengers: Endgame, and I was fortunate enough to recently have the opportunity to ask the perfect people about it. "It's a good theory not gonna lie!" And, perhaps more importantly, would putting the Soul Stone back revive the person who died for it? [2], Decades later, Gamora came to learn of Vormir and its housing of the Soul Stone, keeping this information a secret from Thanos, whom desired all the Infinity Stones to wipe out half of the life in the universe to avoid the extinction of lives by overpopulation. Most of the trip is pretty straight forward, from bringing the Tesseract back to the secret S.H.I.E.L.D. To be able to acquire it, one isrequired a massive sacrifice leading Thanos to give up Gamorajust to wield the gem in Infinity War, and then Black Widow sacrificed herself so that the Avengers can get it for the time heist in Endgame. Captain America Returns The Soul Stone. Movie News This Is Why Marvel Chose Red Skull to Be Tied to the Soul Stone in 'Avengers: Infinity War' By Haleigh Foutch and Diego Peralta Updated Jun 10, 2023 "We knew that we needed to do. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Avengers: Endgame Prelude. Unlike the first five Infinity Stones, which previously made their respective appearances in other MCU movies, the Soul Stone remained a mystery until Infinity War. And that's really where our jumping-off point started with [Markus and McFeely] as well as with [Marvel Studios president and producer] Kevin Feige.". Netflix's First Look At Killer Robots Documentary Is Like Black Mirror Meets Terminator, And It's Nightmare Fuel, Joel McHale Weighs In On Donald Glover And Chevy Chase's Involvement With The Community Movie, And I'm Loving His Atlanta Joke, Aquaman 2s James Wan Explains Why The Lost Kingdom Is Worth Seeing Despite DC Universe Plans, Brett Goldstein Opens Up About Acting Advice From Bryan Cranston Thats Stuck With Him, And How It Applied To The Shrinking Cast, The Rey Movie And James Mangold's Star Wars Film May Be Set In Different Time Periods, But Kathleen Kennedy Says There's A Key Link, Another Streaming Series Bites The Dust At Max, This Time Following HR Complaints, Interview With New Superman David Corenswet About His 'Pie-In-The-Sky Ambition' To Play Kal-El Is Running Around After His Casting, A Swiftie Freaking Out Over Taylor Swift's Surprise Song Went Viral On TikTok, And The Pop Star Had An A+ Response, Trivia Champ James Holzhauer Took A Hilarious Shot At Jeopardy After Wheel Of Fortune Announced Its New Host So Quickly, Critics Have Seen Harrison Ford Indiana Jones And The Dial Of Destiny, And They Have Thoughts About The Harrison Ford Series Swan Song, 6 Reasons Why Match Me Abroad Is The Perfect Show For 90 Day Fianc Fans, What Jack Ryans Abbie Cornish Loved Most About Her Surprise Return In Season 4. Apparently, the reason why it never factored in any prior filmswas because it'son an entirely new planet introduced in the same film - Vormir. After all, in addition to writing both Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame, they also penned the scripts for the entire Captain America trilogy. Please do not make assumptions regarding confusing wording, other sites' speculation, and people's headcanon around the internet. Copyright 2008-2021, GeekTyrant Industries, LLC. Are you like Christopher Markus and truly wish that a Captain America-Red Skull reunion happened on the big screen? The Soul Stone is the only stone requiring a sacrifice before presenting itself to a holder: in Infinity War, Thanos kills favorite daughter Gamora (Zoe Saldana) to unlock the stone, while Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson) sacrifices herself to spare best friend Hawkeye (Jeremy Renner) from death in Endgame. Clint was the eventual survivor. However, a remorseful Thanos sacrificed Gamora in anguish, weeping for her, while earning the Soul Stone for his Infinity Gauntlet soon afterward. Cookie Declaration /// Privacy Policy AVENGERS ENDGAME almost saw Captain America teaming up with Red Skull for the Soul Stone, reveal the screenwriters. The Russos recently spoke about their MCU future, stating they they found their two Avengers films satisfying because they didn't need to think about the future of the franchise, but would return to the series if the right project came along. facility in 1970, to bringing the Power Stone back to Morag in 2014, but of the individual six missions, the returning of the Soul Stone would seem to be a strange and unique challenge. The TikToker frequently talks about Marvel theories on his page. As a result, two of the Infinity Stones -- the Time and Reality Stones -- bonded with humans on Earth. But the film's directors . Reaching the mountains, they were greeted by the Red Skull. All rights reserved. There's no way to know the plan that was discussed, but perhaps this twist could have connected Steve and the Red Skull even more, seeing as how the Skull would become the Soul Stone's guardian. Marvel fans discovered that Ross Marquand played the Red Skull in Avengers Infinity War instead of Hugo Weaving. As audiences will remember, unlike most of the Infinity Stones (which could be taken by the Avengers provided they had proper containment), the Soul Stone was a bit trickier to acquire. "No he spent his time with Peggy," @jabbypop pointed out. In Infinity War, Thanos encountered Schmidt, and perhis edict, sacrificed his adopted daughter Gamora to claim the stone. Here's a New Trailer for TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES: MUTANT MAYHEM, Great Trailer For STAR TREK: STRANGE NEW WORLDS Season 2 Teases New Adventures and LOWER DECKS Crossover, Trailer for Stephen Amell's Wrestling Drama HEELS Season 2, Intense Trailer for the Underwater Survival Thriller THE DIVE, EVIL DEAD RISE Creature Designer Shares Creepy Pics For The Marauder Monster From The Ending, Trailer for the Gunslinger Western Action Film DEAD MAN'S HAND Starring Cole Hauser and Stephen Dorff, Trailer for the Action Thriller DEAD SHOT with Mark Strong and Felicity Jones, Teaser Trailer For Netflix's Intense Religious Dramatic Thriller Series THE CHOSEN ONE Based on the Comic, New Trailer for Steven Soderbergh's Mystery Thriller Series FULL CIRCLE. Occasionally, he's been known to interview creative professionals including comic writers and artists, actors, and musicians. [4] When he went to Vormir, Rogers met with Red Skull for the second time, but rather than showing hostility to each other, Rogers delivered the Stone to Red Skull, who bound to guard it, placed it back to its spot. In the closing scenes of Avengers Endgame, Captain America took the Infinity Stones and Mjolnir back in time, to return them to their original moments in history. Sure, the two explained the mechanics of the Soul Stone with some playful language, likening the Soul Stone's keeper to a pawnbroker and the whole transaction to an old-schoolbank that required customers to put their cash in a little tube and send it shooting inside the building, but the takeaway would be the same even ifMarkus and McFeely gave it to us straight. Going into Avengers: Infinity War, there was a mystery surrounding the Soul Stone. We dont actually see this part of the film play out, but Im sure it mustve been a hell of an adventure for Cap! [5], In an alternate 2301, Vormir had a Nexus event created, but the Time Variance Authority quickly pruned that timeline.[6]. In the MCU, the Infinity Stones were established as small physical gems. Still, the idea of making the Soul Stone an actual . Obsessed with myths, legends, and the occult, Red Skull sought to harness the power of the Tesseract, though his plans would eventually be thwarted by Captain America. But how does that actually work? By George Simpson 14:35, Tue, Jun 26, 2018 . Vormir But then, if that was the case, it means Thanos would have needed to kill yet another Avenger to gain an Infinity Stone. However, the Soul Stone remained, after 18 films, unaccounted for. Discovery and Mattel Celebrate Barbie Movie by Partnering With Save the Children. They have revealed what was going on with Smart Hulk, tried to explain how there were multiple Infinity Gauntlets and why Loki had to be the one who died at the start of Infinity War. Perhaps the most mysterious object in the entire series till the end was the Soul Stone. "Steve had to keep that stone the whole time," he explained. marvel marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-infinity-war captain-america-the-first-avenger Share Which is likely why the idea was dropped as quickly as it was suggested. Christopher Markus: There's a slot. [2], Thanos takes possession of the Soul Stone, In 2018, eventually being forced to reveal the location of the Soul Stone upon seeing her sister Nebula being tortured, Thanos took Gamora to Vormir to find it. Obtaining the Soul Stone was an important plot point in both Infinity War and Endgame, and it cost the lives of both Gamora and Natasha Romanoff. Only the Soul Stone, which even among the six holds a special . "I love Cap and Tony but I feel like their arc ended in endgame and marvel should keep it that way," @uglywoodenpotato explained. Does this take on the Soul Stone jive with your own personal theories following Avengers: Endgame? Yeah, that's right. The consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website. I think it is an everlasting exchange.Christopher Markus: There's a slot.Stephen McFeely: That's right. This is something that has been rumored for a while now, but if the titular heroine is most definitely dead in the Marvel Cinematic Universe then there really arent any other story options available to the filmmakers. Anthony Mackie Was Gunning To Play Black Panther, And His Story About Landing Falcon Instead Is Fascinating, Secret Invasion Revealed A Major Nick Fury Secret, And I'm Here For It, Alan Arkin, Little Miss Sunshine And Argo Star, Dies At 89. You actually have to remember that he got sucked into the Space. But one man on TikTok has a solid theory on why Captain American might not be totally done with the MCU. When previously talking about how things might go down between Cap and Red Skull, director Joe Russo explained: "Red Skull would probably put the soul stone back to its location, and wait for the next unfortunate stone seeker to make a sacrifice. Can DC Still Build A Successful Universe? In our opinion, TikTok creator @toy_blaster_forever was right on the money, but not everyone in the comments section was convinced. Related: Weapons Of Mass Destruction: 11 Deadliest Weapon Plus Super Soldiers Other Than Wolverine. Ian Cardona has written for CBR since 2017. Can't he just escape Vormir once he got there? In 2023, the Avengers initiated a Time Heist in order to resurrect the victims of the Snap, with Hawkeye and Black . Rather than simply being recovered from an amulet or extracted with a special device, obtaining the ingot not only required a trip to the mysterious planet Vormir, but also making an important sacrifice. The Soul Stone was one of the six Infinity Stones, the remnant of a singularity that predated the universe, representing the element of soul. Looking for more TV recommendations and discussion? AVENGERS ENDGAME's Captain America closure must have included an epic reunion. Years later, he realized that what he really felt was just lust. I think it is an everlasting exchange. While Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely's answer was a tad jokey, it seems that once that particular trade is made, there are no takebacks - so despite Cap making the effort to fix the timeline, that particular death is permanent. Matt Goddard Oct 18, 2021 11:13 am Red Skull is one of Captain America 's most dangerous and persistent enemies. It will go over the head of 90% of the audiences," @rayray_ldn argued. Now that Markus and McFeely have seemingly confirmed Black Widow is never coming back from the dead, it appears the only time setting in which the hero's forthcoming standalone can take place is the past. There's one moment of contention among Marvel fans, however the death of Black Widow. As Marvel fans know, one must give up a soul before they can take the Soul Stone and that seemingly poses a problem for Cap's return trip. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. You can follow him on Twitter at @ian_c1701 (yes, that is a Star Trek reference) for discussions, debates or pictures of really cool collectibles he probably doesn't have room for. Directed by Joe and Anthony Russo, Avengers: Endgame stars Robert Downey Jr. as Iron Man, Chris Evans as Captain America, Mark Ruffalo as Bruce Banner, Chris Hemsworth as Thor, Scarlett Johansson as Black Widow, Jeremy Renner as Hawkeye, Brie Larson as Captain Marvel, Paul Rudd as Ant-Man, Don Cheadle as War Machine, Karen Gillan as Nebula, Danai Gurira as Okoye and Bradley Cooper as Rocket, with Gwyneth Paltrow Pepper Potts, Jon Favreau as Happy Hogan, Benedict Wong as Wong, Tessa Thompson as Valkyrie and Josh Brolin as Thanos. It's like an old time bank. While it was already explained that Steve Rogers did come face to face again with Red Skull to return the stone, where does the stone go? Heres how it works. HubPages is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. In the final chapter of the fantasy . The Sorcerer usedvarious tricks during his one-on-one with the Mad Titan, including creating multiple copies of himself to confuse and contain the villain. It worked for a while, until the villainused the Soul Stone to decipher where the real Doctor Strange was. His exile on Vormir, and his destiny to never acquire the Infinity Stones for himself, forged the Red Skull into an indifferent and apathetic guardian of the Soul Stone, not caring who is sacrificed for the stone, only concerned with the criteria for its collection being fulfilled. Nobody will be. [3], Hawkeye takes possession of the Soul Stone, During the Avengers' Time Heist, after traveling the Quantum Realm to an alternate 2014 timeline, Natasha Romanoff and Clint Barton flew in the Benatar to Vormir to collect the Soul Stone. However, it doesn't explain how the Soul Stone is returned. Markus and McFeely explained during a recent episode of CinemaBlend 's HeroBlend podcast that Captain America faced no trouble returning the Soul Stone but sadly, the soul-for-a-soul. Infinity War would finally reveal that the Soul Stone was on a planet called Vormir, and that it was guarded by the Red Skull. The powers of these respective stones was now theirs to master once they realized what had happened to them. Fans were annoyed that the only original female Avenger was the one to be killed off, and that she sacrificed herself so Hawkeye, of all people, didn't have to die. It's like an old time bank. The film is available on Digital HD, Blu-ray and 4K UHD. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. The Soul Stone was unique among the Infinity Stones in Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame, but the original plan was even more different. Avengers: Endgame directors Anthony and Joe Russo reveal they once considered making Captain [], By Cameron Bonomolo That boils down to the original Avengers, and then that boils down even further to the co-leads of the Avengers in Tony Stark and Steve Rogers," Anthony Russo previously told Backstory Magazine. "It's a good question. Would he even really trust to give the Soul Stone to him!? "But what if one stone wasn't returnable? The Infinity Gems (originally referred to as Soul Gems and later as Infinity Stones) are six fictional gems appearing in American comic books published by Marvel Comics, named after and embodying various aspects of existence.The gems can grant whoever wields them various powers in accordance to the aspect of existence they represent, and have the potential of turning the wielder into a god . The exchange is permanent, and the soul that was placed into the "slot" can never be retrieved. Captain America did encounter Red Skull when returning the Soul Stone. A distant relation to that notion instead made it into the final films, where Johann Schmidt, Cap's former enemy The Red Skull, was revealed to be an ethereal spirit serving as the stone's guardian. Cinemablend is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Though Captain America: The First Avenger made it appear as though the Red Skull was transported through space by the Tesseract, his destination wasn't revealed until Avengers: Infinity War. All other Infinity Stones were known of as of the end of Thor: Ragnarok. Continue with Recommended Cookies. But nope! Thanos only used it once in Avengers: Infinity War aside from executing the snap, and it was against Doctor Strange. Head over to our Facebook Group to see new picks every day, and chat with other readers about what they're watching right now. Another unused idea previously revealed by Markus and McFeely would have sent Captain America to Vormir, where he would have had to "collaborate" with Red Skull to retrieve the Soul Stone. He is a Feature, Comic Breakouts and News writer. Hugo Weaving portrayed the Red Skull in Captain America: The First Avenger, but the legendary villain had a very unusual fate in the MCU's Phase 1. The Russos, as well as writers Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely, have been dropping lots of trivia about Endgame and Infinity War as part of the #QuarantineWatchParty tweetalongs. In 1945, the Red Skull vanished from Earth upon holding the Tesseract while trying to finish off Captain America,[1] leading him to be teleported by the Space Stone to Vormir, where he was cursed to serve as the keeper of the Soul Stone. It's unclear how Cap being the Soul Stone would look like on the big screen, the Russos also didn't share how early was this idea formed as they cracked the story for the twin Avengers sequels. AVENGERS 4, the sequel to Avengers Infinity War, will see Iron Man sacrifice Captain America to get the Soul Stone, according to an amazing fan theory. Once the Mad Titan Thanos and his adoptive daughter Gamora journey to Vormir to acquire the Soul Stone in Infinity War, the pair is met by a ghostly apparition who reveals himself as the aged form of the Red Skull. Since Red skull is free after the Soul . Captain America: The First Avenger (2011). If you're nice, he can be found on Twitter as @QuiGonJimm. .css-6owf8s{display:block;font-family:Montserrat,Helvetica,Arial,Sans-serif;font-weight:400;letter-spacing:0.025rem;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;text-transform:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-6owf8s:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.3;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.3;}}@media(min-width: 48rem){.css-6owf8s{text-align:center;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.3125rem;line-height:1.2;}}What's happening in Marvel Phase 6? Evidently, someone can't just say that they don't want the Soul Stone anymore and will give it up to get back the soul they sacrificed. And while one could hope that perhaps someday well get to see a movie that features Captain Americas version of Infinity Watch, it sadly sounds like thats never going to happen. Theorizing about how Steve Rogers could have possibly been the Soul Stone leads to many questions, and these questions are likely why the Russo Brothers dropped the idea rather quickly. Copyright 2023 ComicBook.com. Home / movies How Did Red Skull Get To Vormir? Comic Despite these changes and other abandoned ideas including a scene that would have depicted a time-traveling Thanos tossing the decapitated head of Captain America the Endgame creative team worked out endings for Captain America and Iron Man (Robert Downey Jr.) first before working backwards from there: "We knew the goal of these films was to provide an ending for this epic 10-year journey of 22 movies in the MCU, so we started from the endpoint, which was, 'Let's figure out where our central characters end.' All rights reserved. Last week I had the pleasure of interviewing screenwriters Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely for the latest episode of our HeroBlend podcast, and I made it a personal priority to ask them about the Soul Stone. Marvel delays Captain America and Avengers release, How Avengers group chat reacted to Renner accident, Chris Hemsworth's new Transformers movie delayed, Ant-Man 3 writer denies leaking Marvel secrets, Avengers director mocks Tom Holland over spoilers, Avengers stars reunite for new Transformers movie, James Gunn disagrees with this Infinity War scene, GotG's James Gunn confirms MCU return for actor, Avengers duo keen to direct Batman movie for DCU, DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK. This scene . "Steve Rogers became the new protector of the soul stone.". He has also written for other various comics-related publications and websites, covered comic conventions, and appeared in video commentaries. RELATED: Endgame Confirmed the Strongest Avenger Isn't Thor, Hulk OR Captain Marvel. How did he successfully return the Soul Stone? Celestials To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. Notable inhabitants Movie "So we're lead to believe he returned all the stones and lived happily ever after," he added. Captain America is the Soul Stone? Appearances Marvel Cinematic Universe Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. IfMarkus and McFeely are to be believed without a shadow of a doubt, if there truly is no way that Nat can be resurrected, then there isn't any other point in time thatBlack Widow screenwriter Jac Schaeffercan place the film other than years before the events ofAvengers: Endgame. Endgame's Star-Lord Dance Used NO Footage From Guardians of the Galaxy, Endgame Cosplay: MCU Fans Build Fan-Favorite Armor Entirely On 3D-Printer, War Machine Deserves His Own MCU Solo Film (Or Disney+ Series). Endgame continues its tear across the box office, currently settling in as the second highest-grossing film of all-time with a worldwide haul of over $2.19 billion.James Cameron's Avatar continues . With viewers' limited time with the Soul Stone, it's quite unclear how it actually works. Christopher Markus:Because I very much wanted like, 'How are we not getting Cap into space to see the Red Skull? And it just otherwise was not the story to tell for Cap, but it is extremely tempting. Jim is a freelance writer who started writing for CBR in 2013. Related:Captain America Theory: Endgame's Repaired Shield Proves Steve Changed Timelines. How one can return the Soul stone ( obviously, not putting the stone on Vormir) Well, we don't actually know how but it seems likely and we have no reason to assume otherwise that it can just be returned to Vormir.